- Convenors:
-
Aurel Baele
Lun Jing (Leiden University)
Send message to Convenors
- Discussant:
-
Hiromu NAGAHARA
(Massachusetts Institute of Technology)
- Format:
- Panel
- Section:
- Media Studies
Short Abstract
This panel challenges the notion of Tokyo’s centrality in Japan’s postwar music industry on the intersection of media, gender, and resistance. The aim is to question the taken-for-granted historiographies by examining how narratives, visibility, and sites of opposition produced since 1945.
Long Abstract
This panel challenges the notion of Tokyo’s centrality in Japan’s postwar music industry on the intersection of media, gender, and resistance. The four presentations each offer a unique case study to approach Japanese popular music as a discursive space shaped by media institutions and industrial power. Together they question the taken-for-granted historiographies by examining how narratives, visibility, and sites of opposition have been actively produced since 1945.
Paper one problematizes the heavily Tokyo-centered historiography of Japan’s postwar popular music and its industry which has shaped both cultural production and historical knowledge. Instead, it takes Osaka’s vibrant music scene of the 1970s-80s as a productive case to demonstrate how dominant historical narratives have obscured alternative forms of cultural organization.
The next paper connects the previous issue with radio broadcasting. It explores the reconfiguration and recovery of the music industry in the reshaped media landscape during the Occupation of Japan (1945-1952). It takes the NHK radio program Shirouto nodo jiman (The Layperson’s Singing Contest) and its contemporary derivatives by record companies as a case.
Paper three builds up on the connection between radio and the music industry. It investigates the power dynamics and sociocultural connotations of the non-participatory phenomenon in NHK’s Kōhaku utagassen (Red and White Song Battle) of the 1970s to demonstrate the agency of singers and the power relationships between the various stakeholders in the entertainment industry.
The last paper examines chanson in postwar Japan arguing that the music genre functioned as a medium through which non-normative expressions of gender and sexuality became articulable within Japanese popular music culture. It demonstrates that gender-transgressive performers were central to the development of popular song forms rather than peripheral through the cases of Miwa Akihiro and Simone Fukayuki.
Then, all of these papers together contribute to popular music studies, media studies, and media history by providing unique useful cases to reconsider Japan’s postwar music scene.
Keywords:
broadcasting media, power dynamics and relationships, music industry, centrality versus periphery, French chanson, queer culture, historiography, Osaka, Tokyo, NHKyo, NHK
| Abstract in Japanese (if needed) | 本パネルは、戦後日本のポピュラー音楽史において自明視されてきた「東京中心性」を、メディア、ジェンダー、抵抗の観点から問い直すことを目的とする。とりわけ、1945年以降に形成されてきた歴史叙述や可視性、抵抗の場に着目し、東京中心性がいかなる制度的条件のもとで形成されてきたのか、それをいかにして再構築していくかを検討する。 本パネルを構成する4つの発表は、それぞれ異なる事例研究を通じて、日本のポピュラー音楽を、メディア制度や産業的権力によって形作られてきた言説空間として捉えるものである。最初の2つの発表はマクロな視点をとる。最初の発表は、戦後日本のポピュラー音楽史および音楽産業において支配的であった東京中心的なヒストリオグラフィが、文化的実践のみならず歴史的知の枠組みそのものを規定してきた点を問題化する。そのうえで、1970〜80年代の大阪における音楽文化を分析対象とし、支配的な歴史叙述が代替的な文化組織や実践をいかに覆い隠してきたのかを明らかにする。第二の発表はこの問題をラジオ放送と結びつけ、占領期(1945〜52)に再編されたメディア環境のもとで、音楽産業がいかに再構築・回復していったのかを検討する。具体的には、NHKラジオ番組『素人のど自慢』と、レコード会社によるその派生的企画を事例とする。 対して、後半の2つの発表はよりミクロな視点をとる。第三の発表は、ラジオと音楽産業の関係を踏まえつつ、1970年代のNHK『紅白歌合戦』における「能動的不参加」という現象を分析し、歌手の主体性や、放送局・レコード会社・芸能事務所といった関係者間の権力関係を明らかにする。最後の発表は、戦後日本におけるシャンソンを、クィアおよびアウトサイダー文化の場として捉える。1950〜60年代における美輪明宏の活動を通じて、フランス文化の再解釈と特定のパフォーマンス空間が、ジェンダー越境、クィアな可視性、そして代替的な文化的正統性をいかに可能にしてきたのかを論じる。これら四つの発表を通じて、本パネルは、日本の戦後ポピュラー音楽をめぐる歴史叙述を、ポピュラー音楽研究、メディア研究、メディア史の観点から再考するための有効な事例を提示する。 。 |
Accepted papers
Paper short abstract
This paper reexamines Tokyo-centered historiographies of postwar Japanese popular music by treating media-industrial centralization as a historical problem. Focusing on Osaka’s music cultures of the 1970s–80s, it reveals alternative conditions of production overlooked by dominant narratives.
Paper long abstract
This paper reframes Tokyo-centered narratives of postwar Japanese popular music by foregrounding the structural centralization of media industries in the capital. Existing histories have often treated Tokyo-based institutions—record companies, publishers, broadcasters, and distribution networks—as implicit norms, producing accounts that appear national while in fact reflecting highly concentrated media-industrial conditions. As a result, the institutional and spatial biases embedded in these narratives have remained largely unquestioned.
Rather than treating such concentration as a neutral background, this paper approaches media-industrial centralization itself as a historical problem. It argues that the dominance of Tokyo-based cultural industries shaped not only patterns of musical production, circulation, and promotion, but also the evaluative frameworks through which popular music has been assessed, canonized, and written into history. Tokyo-centered institutional arrangements thus came to define what has been recognized as historically significant within postwar Japanese popular music.
To examine the implications of this structure, the paper takes Osaka as an analytically productive case. From the late 1970s through the 1980s, Osaka sustained vibrant music cultures grounded in locally based infrastructures, including live venues, independent production and distribution networks, and regionally oriented cultural economies. In particular, practices associated with blues, folk, post-punk, and noise music often developed earlier or along different trajectories than their counterparts in Tokyo. These practices emerged under media-industrial conditions fundamentally different from those centered in the capital.
Rather than positioning Osaka as a peripheral or oppositional anomaly, this paper treats it as a case that clarifies the limits of Tokyo-centered historiography. By examining how Osaka-based musical practices have been situated within dominant historical narratives, the paper highlights the assumptions and evaluative criteria that have shaped postwar Japanese popular music history. The focus is not on recovering neglected scenes for inclusion into an existing canon, but on questioning the historiographical frameworks through which such canons have been constructed.
Through this reorientation, the paper contributes to Media Studies and Japanese Studies by showing how media-industrial centralization has shaped both cultural production and historical knowledge. It proposes a framework for reassessing postwar Japanese popular music that foregrounds institutional structure and spatial differentiation, moving beyond Tokyo-centered narratives.
| Abstract in Japanese (if needed): | 本発表は、戦後日本のポピュラー音楽史において自明視されてきた「東京中心的」な歴史叙述を、首都に集中したメディア産業構造そのものを歴史的問題として捉え直すことで再検討するものである。従来の日本ポピュラー音楽史は、レコード会社、出版社、放送局、流通網といった東京所在の制度や組織を暗黙の基準としてきたため、全国的な歴史を描いているように見えながら、実際には高度に集権化されたメディア産業の条件を反映したものとなってきた。 本発表は、こうした集中構造を所与の背景として扱うのではなく、それ自体がいかに音楽の生産・流通のあり方だけでなく、「何が歴史的に重要な音楽として認識されるのか」という評価基準やカノン(聖典)化の枠組みを形成してきたのかを明らかにする。その上で、東京中心の文化産業が、戦後日本のポピュラー音楽をどのように理解し、記述するかという知の枠組みそのものを規定してきた点を検討する。 この構造の含意を考察するため、本発表では関西の大都市である大阪を分析上の重要な事例として取り上げる。1970〜80年代にかけて、大阪ではライブハウス、独立系の制作・流通ネットワーク、地域志向の文化経済を基盤とする活発な音楽文化が展開していた。とりわけ、日本におけるブルースやフォーク、さらにはポストパンクやノイズ・ミュージックといった実践において、大阪は東京に先行する動きを見せていた側面もある。これらの音楽文化は、単に中央メディアから周縁化されていたのではなく、東京を中心とするメディア産業とは異なる条件のもとで成立していた点に特徴がある。なお本発表は、大阪を周縁的な例外として位置づけるのではなく、東京中心的ヒストリオグラフィの限界を可視化する分析的なケースとして捉える。その目的は、見過ごされてきた音楽シーンを既存の正典に回収することではなく、戦後日本のポピュラー音楽史がいかなる前提や枠組みによって構築されてきたのかを問い直すことである。 以上の検討を通じて、本発表は、メディア産業の集権化が文化実践のみならず歴史的知識の形成にも与えてきた影響を示し、東京中心的な視座を相対化することで、戦後日本ポピュラー音楽史を再考するための理論的枠組みを提示する。 |
Paper short abstract
This historical paper examines the power dynamics and sociocultural connotations of the non-participants in the NHK Red and White Song Battle (kōhaku utagassen) in the 1970s, with a particular focus on the agency of music artists and their power relationships with the mass media and music industry.
Paper long abstract
This paper examines the power dynamics and sociocultural connotations of the non-participatory phenomenon in the NHK Red and White Song Battle (kōhaku utagassen) in the 1970s with a particular focus on music artists. Often abbreviated as “Kōhaku,” the TV-radio program is an ongoing annual music special produced and broadcast live by Japan’s public broadcaster NHK and has achieved the highest-ever audience ratings among all regular programs in Japanese television history. Beginning around the 14th event in 1963, Kōhaku had gradually developed into a yearly national media event. Consequently, a music artist’s appearance on Kōhaku started to become a benchmark for measuring their popularity and career success, and their “Kōhaku experience” would even influence the level of their appearance fees when performing in local venues. On the other hand, an increasing number of newly debuted singers tended to view performing on Kōhaku as a prestigious honor and their major career goal. However, when it came to the 1970s, a group of singers that moved against the trend to voluntarily opt out of Kōhaku emerged. They deliberately distanced themselves from Kōhaku or even declined the offer from NHK to appear on the stage, despite the fact that they had major hits that year and thus being strong candidates for the grand show’s lineup. In the context of Kōhaku being institutionalized as a sociocultural ritual that took on the function of uniting the nation as a virtual community at the temporal threshold between the old year and the new, the invisuality, invisibility, inaudibility, and non-cooperativeness of those non-participants came to embody more than a mere absence. Rather, such non-participation constituted an antithesis of Kōhaku’s televised mainstreamness as well as a countervailing force against NHK’s mediated power and, by extension, the conservative discourse as well as the centralized narrative of homogeneity within Japanese society in the postwar Showa period. Through historical investigation, this paper explores not only the agency of those discontented or nonchalant singers but also the power relationships and behind-the-screen negotiations among the singers, NHK, commercial TV broadcasters, record companies, and talent agencies within the highly intricate and interactive network of Kōhaku.
Paper short abstract
This paper reconsiders the reconfiguration Japan’s music industry of the immediate postwar years. It takes the NHK radio program Shirouto nodo jiman (The Layperson’s Singing Contest) and its contemporary derivatives by record companies as focal point.
Paper long abstract
This paper reconsiders the centrality of Tokyo in the reconfiguration Japan’s music industry during the immediate postwar years. In this period, radio is considered a crucial medium for the dissemination of hits while record companies were still recovering from the Second World War. As radio broadcasting was democratized under supervision of the Allied forces, the dominance of the capital was also, arguably, in question. To demonstrate that, the paper takes the NHK radio program Shirouto nodo jiman (The Layperson’s Singing Contest, often shortened to Nodo jiman) with its contemporary derivatives contests held by record companies nationwide, as focal point.
Nodo jiman was launched on 19 January 1946 and featured a selection of amateur contestants on a weekly basis who competed against each other by performing a freely chosen song. During the hard socio-economic conditions of the latter half of the 1940s, the show was highly popular among all layers the population – children, students, salarymen, shopkeepers, and housewives alike. Its success was a combination of the amateurish level of its participants and bringing local talent to the national level during a time of democratization under supervision of the Allied Forces. Moreover, several famous postwar artists, such as Misora Hibari and Sakurai Chōichirō, had participated in the contest.
In contrast, record companies were still reeling from the outfall of the war. American bombers had destroyed their factories and recording studios. In addition, the production of gramophones and records was still low as resources were expensive and most households still held on to radio sets which were more affordable. Nevertheless, such companies continued their business with hits by existing composers, lyricists, and performers. On the other hand, Nodo jiman proved an interesting format to recruit new talent and attract visibility as record companies also launched their own imitations of and collaborated with NHK.
This paper argues that such perspective allows a more nuanced view of the recording industry’s recovery in postwar Japan in relation to the changed media landscape without reducing record companies’ operations as profit based.
Paper short abstract
This paper traces the history of French chanson in postwar Japan as a medium for gender-transgressive performance. Focusing on the Takarazuka Revue, Miwa Akihiro, and Simone Fukayuki, it examines how queer aesthetics and performance were central to the formation of Japanese popular song.
Paper long abstract
This paper offers a historical examination of French chanson in Japan, arguing that chanson functioned as a medium through which non-normative expressions of gender and sexuality became articulable within Japanese popular music culture. In Japan, chanson refers to French popular songs from the late 19th to early 20th century that circulated amid the rapid influx of music from Europe and the Americas. Like many yōgaku (Western music) genres, chanson entered Japan through processes of translation and adaptation, from its first introduction by the all-female Takarazuka Girls’ Revue. Their 1927 stage production “Mon Paris” marked a pivotal moment in which women’s cross-dressing performance framed Paris as a modern fantasy defined by cultivated luxury, erotic alterity, and urban sophistication.
Chanson reached new prominence during the postwar “Chanson Boom” of the 1950s and 1960s, when the genre came to be newly composed in Japanese. Central to this movement was Miwa Akihiro, widely recognized as the first openly gay singer-songwriter to achieve mainstream success in Japan. Miwa’s theatrical vocality, extravagant costuming, and androgynous beauty expanded chanson’s expressive possibilities within Japanese linguistic and cultural contexts, transforming it into a site where queer subjectivities were rendered visible and audible within the commercial entertainment industry.
By tracing a critical genealogy of chanson and its aesthetic conventions as reinterpreted in postwar Japan, this paper demonstrates that gender-transgressive performers were not peripheral but central to the development of popular song forms. Building on scholarship that examines Orientalist tropes in Western art music as a means of projecting societally disavowed desires onto a colonial Other, this paper proposes that French chanson was inversely mobilized as a vehicle through which Japanese singers materialized such desires onto a Western Other, thereby enabling alternative gender expressions within mainstream popular culture.
The paper concludes with a case study of contemporary chanson singer and drag queen Simone Fukayuki’s adaptation of Charles Aznavour’s “Les Faux” (1969), retitled “Itsuwari” (1994). Simone’s concept of “opulent lies” is theorized as a queer aesthetic of musical translation that embraces imitation and artifice, reconfiguring the “fake” not as derivative, but as a productive force in the history of Japanese popular song.