Click the star to add/remove an item to/from your individual schedule.
You need to be logged in to avail of this functionality.
Log in
- Convenors:
-
Rijk van Dijk
(African Studies Centre Leiden)
Thomas G. Kirsch (University of Konstanz)
Send message to Convenors
- Stream:
- Religion
- Location:
- Chrystal McMillan, Seminar Room 2
- Sessions:
- Thursday 13 June, -
Time zone: Europe/London
Short Abstract:
In Africa today, religious groups are adopting activist registers of discourse and practice. Claiming to heal social divisions, they also produce new social asymmetries. The panel addresses the uneasy coexistence of these facets of religious activism: its integrative power and its disruptive effects
Long Abstract:
In many places in Africa today, religious groups are increasingly adopting activist registers of discourse and practice in their attempts to (re)define the place of religion in society. Often, such religious activism is addressing matters of sexual health & rights, relationships, social inequality and environmental issues. In the majority of cases, religious activists do so against the backdrop of their perception that social realities are rife with tensions and misalignments, and that people's life-worlds thus need to be transformed in divinely ordained ways. In order to do so, religious activists engage with certain groups of people, connecting with them in new ways and establishing new forms of sociality. In this process, however, certain other groups of people are either deliberately or inadvertently "disconnected", left out, alienated, which in itself is marking a new repositioning of religion in African societies. In other words, while religious activism often claims to aim at the "common good" and to overcome social divisions, it is at the same time producing new social asymmetries and inequalities in society on the basis of proclaiming and following certain tenets of faith. The panel invites contributions based on ethnographic findings from different parts of Africa and relating to different religious traditions that address the uneasy coexistence of these two dimensions of religious activism: its integrative power and forms of community-building on the one hand, and its divisive and socially disruptive effects on the other.
Accepted papers:
Session 1 Thursday 13 June, 2019, -Paper short abstract:
The paper analyses 'reform' as a modality of activism that aims at the construction of a 'new' self-understanding for men and the establishment of a 'new' form of solidarity among them. The paper discusses the socially integrative and disruptive effects of this process.
Paper long abstract:
In South Africa, the calls of Pentecostal actors for men to return "to the original plan of God" and to "rise up" against the various challenges that the post-apartheid society is facing are growing ever louder. Through the provision of biblical knowledge and spiritual stability men's ministries seek to reform men's behaviour and refashion notions of masculinity deploying ideas of a "continued renewing" and "moral regeneration". Their expectations concerning male gender roles put emphasis on values such as responsibility, male headship, self-discipline, and respectfulness towards women and other men. Drawing on ethnographic research in metropolitan areas of Gauteng province, the paper analyses 'reform' as a modality of activism that aims at the construction of a 'new' self-understanding for men and the establishment of a 'new' form of solidarity among them. In a context of socio-economic insecurity, Christian men's groups claim to provide conditions for social and emotional stability. As 'reform' promises the prospect to become part of a religious community that is characterised, among other things, by stable family relations, economic security, non-violent relationships, and reliability, there seems to be a link between 'reform' and 'social integration'. As I will show, however, the 'reform' endeavour produces asymmetries between the members of these men's groups on the one hand and the 'ordinary', i.e. 'not-yet-reformed', men on the other. While some men are excluded completely and considered as 'unreformable', others are marginalised within the 'movement'. The paper discusses the socially integrative and disruptive effects of this process.
Paper short abstract:
I discuss religious-activism in Zargulla(Ethiopia) used to delegitimize the core cultural practice of clan-based burial. I analyze reflections of two members of the Evangelical-Christian church and processes of inclusion and exclusion around burial
Paper long abstract:
I discuss the consequences of religious activism in Zargulla (Ethiopia) used to delegitimize the core cultural practice of clan-based burial in this society. I analyze 3 video-clips with reflections of two members of the Evangelical-Christian church regarding their protest actions which resulted in two major changes in the community: the first involved the decision of Evangelical-Christians (in the 1980s) to not adhere to the tradition of clan-based burial. I.e., all Christians irrespective of clan could in principle be buried in the same cemetery. However, in practice, this change was not extended to the Christian Mana (the occupation-based caste group comprising potters, tanners and blacksmiths), since non-Mana Christians vehemently refused to have a Christian Mana buried close to the tombs of their loved ones. The second change took place about ten years ago, and was initiated by agitation by young Evangelical-Christians, backed by some local government officials, against the exclusion of Christian Mana from burial grounds designated for Christians. Using various tricks as well as violence against their own families (including physical fights and imprisonment) they then managed to bury the first Christian Mana in a cemetery where other Christians were buried. Consequently, inclusion of Mana meant alienation of elderly and less-educated Zargulla. This paper discusses the discursive battles involved in these processes or change.
Paper short abstract:
Building on stories from people from the SOGI community and their nearest and dearest in Gaborone, I show how messages from Christian leaders about sexuality and their offer to 'cure' homosexuals leads to divisions within families and communities through fear, shame, gossip, and violence.
Paper long abstract:
Many Batswana from the SOGI community find themselves questioned, sworn at, and left out because their sexual orientation or gender identity is seen as demonic and immoral. In this paper I build on stories I collected during my fieldwork to elaborate on how the influence of Christian leaders regarding sexuality and their offer to 'cure' homosexuals or transgender persons 'back to normal' leads to divisions within families and communities. Christianity is important in Botswana, and shapes attitudes. During public discussions on sexuality and sexual rights, various Christian leaders got involved in the debate, usually condemning queer relationships and genders. Batswana often refer to the God, the Devil, demons or biblical stories if sexuality is the topic of conversation, echoing the message many religious leaders spread. People with queer sexual orientations or gender identities are othered and labelled as people who need fixing based on what Batswana learned about men, women, and sexuality from religious leaders. The negative stories about the SOGI community lead to fear to come out and the fear of rejection and to shame and gossip, and is used as a justification for public and domestic violence as a way to instill moral behaviour. The nearest and dearest of queer people also struggle with fear, shame, and gossip as they are confronted with the queerness of their family member or friend and have to find a way to cope with that, often closely watched and questioned by family and the community, including religious leaders.