Click the star to add/remove an item to/from your individual schedule.
You need to be logged in to avail of this functionality.
Log in
- Convenor:
-
Birgit Meyer
(Utrecht University)
Send message to Convenor
- Location:
- B2.01
- Start time:
- 27 June, 2013 at
Time zone: Europe/Lisbon
- Session slots:
- 1
Short Abstract:
The aim of this panel is to take stock of recent initiatives in the study of Christian and Islamic movements and to consider the theoretical implications of placing their study in one conceptual framework. What new questions and research themes emerge?
Long Abstract:
In many parts of contemporary Africa, the Christian and Islamic worlds rub against, and interact with each other, in arenas of diversity and pluralism. Yet so far research on Islam and Christianity has mainly been conducted in two quite distinct fields with their own scholarly communities, themes and debates. But recently scholars have started to venture into comparative research, exploring similarities and differences, as well as mutual influences and interactions between Islam and Christianity, particularly as regards Islamic Reformist and Pentecostal-Charismatic movements. The use of similar media, attitudes towards urban space, practices of piety, attitudes towards "traditional religion," identity politics, etc. have proved to be productive entry points for comparative study. The aim of this panel is to take stock of these initiatives and to consider the theoretical implications of placing the study of Islam and Christianity in one conceptual framework. What new questions and research themes emerge? What are the potentials and limitations of looking for similarities, overlaps, interactions and mixtures between Christian and Islamic movements? Does a focus on similarities make scholars underplay crucial differences? How might this field of study be further developed?
Accepted papers:
Session 1Brian Larkin (Barnard College, Columbia University)
Paper short abstract:
In this paper I examine the lability of religious forms analyzing how new Islamic movements came to use the genres, speech forms, and institutional arrangements of evangelical Christianity as part of the constitution of Islamic revival.
Paper long abstract:
Religions are encoded in discursive and circulatory forms through which they are constituted and their claims enabled. Religious services, revival meetings, television programs, mosque lessons, public loudspeakers are just some of the myriad ways in which religions are made manifest in the world. As they do so they enter into public engagement with other religious movements within and across religions as well as with a broader secular world. I have been interested in what happens when those forms are promiscuous - when one religious public takes the discursive forms used to constitute another public. Sometimes these forms are labile so that the 'borrowing' from one realm to another goes unremarked. At other times there is an immanence between a form and the theologies that animate it so that any borrowing becomes a metareflexive commentary. In this paper I wish to examine how the emergence of forms used to constitute a secular public were adopted by Muslim reformists in northern Nigeria and, later, how new Islamic movements came to use the genres, speech forms, and institutional arrangements of evangelical Christianity as part of the constitution of Islamic revival. I examine this through practices of loudspeaker use and of religious evangelizing.
Marloes Janson (SOAS, University of London)
Paper short abstract:
This paper questions conventional assumptions of Christian-Muslim interactions in terms of a “clash of civilizations” and focuses instead on the convergence between the two religious traditions, thereby crossing boundaries and blurring sharp distinctions.
Paper long abstract:
The proposed paper presents an ethnographic case study to explore the rise and expansion of "Chrislam", a series of religious movements that mix Christian and Muslim beliefs and practices in their socio-cultural and political setting in Nigeria's former capital Lagos. Nigeria is an interesting context in which to study Chrislam because its population, which is almost equally divided between Christians and Muslims, has increasingly become involved in religious violence. However, my paper illustrates that religious clashes are just one aspect of Christian-Muslim manifold relations in Nigeria. Lagos presents a challenging site for mapping the spiritual means that Chrislam offers its worshippers to deliver them from the socio-political anxiety and economic hardships that characterize their everyday lives. At a time when born-again Christianity and reformist Islam are among the world's fastest-growing religious traditions, this paper suggests that the expansion of Chrislam has to be seen as a part of a wider move towards "Islamic Pentecostalism". Placing Chrislam worshippers' perceptions of their own religiosity and their lived experiences at centre stage, it questions conventional assumptions of Christian-Muslim interactions in terms of a "clash of civilizations" and focuses instead on the convergence between the two religious traditions, thereby crossing boundaries and blurring sharp distinctions.