Click the star to add/remove an item to/from your individual schedule.
You need to be logged in to avail of this functionality.
Log in
- Convenors:
-
Emma Tomalin
(University of Leeds)
Shabaana Kidy (Humanitarian Academy for Development)
- Stream:
- A: Actors in addressing inequality
- Location:
- C16
- Start time:
- 28 June, 2018 at
Time zone: Europe/London
- Session slots:
- 1
Short Abstract:
This panel will critically examine the role of faith actors in combating modern slavery and human-trafficking, as well as the ways in which religious identities are pertinent in the trafficking domain (e.g. for trafficked individuals, activists, those providing services and for perpetrators).
Long Abstract:
Although estimates are contested and data collection is poor, the Global Slavery Index tells us that '45.8 million people are enslaved in the world today'; the International Labour Organisation (ILO) estimate is that profits from human trafficking are $150billion annually; and UNICEF tells us that at least 1.2 million children are trafficked every year. Strong advocacy by many groups attests both to the gravity of the problem and considerable impetus to address it. Faith actors are important in anti-trafficking advocacy, and often play a positive role in support and service provision. Moreover, for many trafficked people a faith commitment is an important part of their identity. However, religious identities can be relevant to issues of human trafficking and modern slavery negatively. For instance, religious teachings may underpin unequal gender relations that enable sexual and labour exploitation; faith communities may choose to ignore trafficked people, viewing their situation as the product of unwholesome life style choices that are at odds with faith based values; faith based institutions may support practices that result in the trafficking of people (e.g. 'forced marriage' and other harmful traditional practices) or traffickers may use religion as a means of coercion. What roles do faith actors play in in providing services to support trafficked people, and in campaigns to end human-trafficking and modern slavery? How are religious identities pertinent in the trafficking domain? (e.g. for trafficked individuals, those providing services, activists seeking to end trafficking and for perpetrators).
Accepted papers:
Session 1Paper short abstract:
This paper presents the research findings from anti-trafficking work in the Middle East with East African women. This work presents the importance of faith in female economic migrants integration. The women expressed their Christian identity created greater risk for exploitation in the region.
Paper long abstract:
This abstract is based on doctoral research conducted in the Middle East. The research methodology was grounded in ethnography and a case study approach where two American evangelical anti-trafficking organisations were observed as they worked with East African women. This paper reports on one emerging issue of the empirical findings. As increased attention is given to issues of trafficking and illegal migration understanding the construction of women's identities is needed to explore the intersection of faith, migration, and resilience. The fragile migration status of female economic migrants in the Middle East needs recognition as a complex reality resulting in few options for assistance. Broadly, the current literature presents the challenges encountered in migration and integration, yet knowledge is still needed in the context of the Middle East. The findings presented highlight the complexity of women's identities and how this influenced decision encountered during integration. The women identified their connection to faith-based networks, within their ethnic group and with the American anti-trafficking organisation, as a more favourable factor in securing domestic service employment and building a social network. This paper presents that faith is integral in women's decision making and in their capacity to survive extreme situations. Furthermore, the strong association with their faith identity as Christians appeared to increase their risk of vulnerability in the region. Finally, this work presents the importance of anti-trafficking organisations positively acknowledging migrant women's faith and the positive network connections that can be made in their migration projects.
Paper short abstract:
Chab Dai is a coalition of over 50 faith based NGOs focusing on modern day slavery in Cambodia. The Butterfly project is a longitudinal research project involving over 100 participants who have been sexually exploited and then been through faith based programs and reintegrated over a ten year period
Paper long abstract:
Chab Dai is a coalition of over 50 faith based NGOs focusing on modern day slavery in Cambodia. The Butterfly project is a longitudinal research project involving over 100 participants who have been sexually exploited and then been through 14 faith residential and community based programs and reintegrated over a ten year period. Some of the findings of this research will be presented especially the impact of faith and spirituality. Although most of the participants came from Folk Buddhist backgrounds and some returned to these traditional roots, others found comfort, healing and support from Christian beliefs. Nearly all participants were clear that they did not feel coerced to change their beliefs. The paper will discuss some of the positive and possibly negative teachings of different experienced religions; Christianity, Folk Buddhism, Chinese Taoism and Traditional Spirit Worship/Healing. It will also look at how participants see the impact that these beliefs have on their lives today, sometimes years after completing the programmes. It will make recommendations to policy makers and practitioners on spiritual care vs. spiritual abuse and suggest inclusion of spirituality as part of holistic care of children and vulnerable people.
Paper short abstract:
This paper examines the rhetorical framing of communicative artifacts of human trafficking, and analyzes it against on-ground data from the Greater Mekong Sub-region.
Paper long abstract:
The rhetoric of victimhood is a prominent feature of Christian organizational responses to human trafficking. Such an emphasis often lacks a holistic approach against exploitation. There is a disparity between the rhetorical framing of trafficking in communicative artifacts, such as books, films, and social media, and the on-ground realities faced by trafficked people in prominent trafficking zones such as the Greater Mekong Sub-region. This paper examines the rhetorical framing of communicative artifacts of human trafficking and analyzes it against on-ground data from the Greater Mekong Sub-region. Victimization is inherently damaging and dehumanizing. It perpetuates myths of trafficked people's lived experiences. Moving past the rhetoric of victimhood is essential for Christian organizations to better align with holistic responses to human trafficking in Southeast Asia.
Paper short abstract:
The paper critically reflects on the history of the 18th century Methodist movement in Britain and Southern Africa to offer new insights on how the Methodist Church of Southern African can involve itself in the fight against human trafficking in the 21 century.
Paper long abstract:
The paper aims to offer a brief historical account of the early Methodist Movement's involvement in Britain within the anti-slavery and labour movements of the late 18th century. Methodism then took root in other parts of world; thus this paper also seeks explore the involvement of early Southern African Wesleyan Missionaries and their role in advocating for the abolition of the trans-Atlantic slave trade. Fundamentally, the aim of this inquiry is to draw insights from the past Methodist activism to offer fresh perspectives on how the Methodist Church of Southern Africa can best engage itself in providing services to support trafficked people, and in campaigns to end human-trafficking and modern slavery.