to star items.

P084


Who Has the Right to Decide? Refusal, Reciprocity and Ethnographic Authority 
Convenors:
Panas Karampampas (Durham University)
Ili Chrysikou (University College Cork)
Send message to Convenors
Format:
Panel

Short Abstract

What happens when people challenge an ethnographer’s account or refuse the terms of research? This panel explores how authority is negotiated through feedback, disagreement and reciprocity, and asks who ultimately decides how ethnographic knowledge is produced and used.

Long Abstract

Anthropologists are increasingly expected to work collaboratively and remain accountable to the people whose lives inform their research. But what happens when those people disagree with our interpretations, object to how they are represented, or refuse the terms on which we propose to work? These are not merely practical difficulties. They bring into view an unresolved question about the authority to produce ethnographic knowledge.

This panel considers how authority is negotiated during fieldwork and long after it ends. We are interested in moments when interlocutors question an account, ask to revise or withdraw material, challenge a publication, or expect something in return that researchers cannot readily offer. Such encounters expose the limits of consent and the tensions between relationships in the field and the demands of universities, funders and publishers. They also invite us to ask whether feedback changes decisions or simply gives participants an opportunity to respond to decisions already made.

We welcome ethnographically grounded contributions from any setting, including heritage, activism, health, environmental research and digital worlds. Papers might explore refusal, contested representation, reciprocity, research afterlives or collaborations that do not result in agreement.

Rather than treat participation as evidence that authority has been shared, we ask where decisions actually lie, how they can be challenged and what anthropologists owe those who challenge them.


Propose paper