to star items.

P082


1 paper proposal Propose
Uncertainty, consensus, and storytelling: the construction and deconstruction of scientific authority in environmental movements and discourses. 
Convenor:
Molly Foster (University of Greenwich)
Send message to Convenor
Format:
Panel

Short Abstract

How do environmental movements defer to, selectively invoke, or contest scientific authority? This panel explores knowledge-making, storytelling, and polarisation across environmental movements, asking how actors position themselves under, with, or against “the science.”

Long Abstract

Environmental movements routinely stake their legitimacy on relationships to scientific authority — some positioning themselves as aligned with settled consensus, others characterising dominant metrics and institutions as reductive or incomplete. This panel asks how such positioning is constructed, justified, and contested across environmental movements, and whether it contributes to polarisation within environmental and sustainability debates. We invite ethnographically grounded papers examining how activists, organisations, and movements relate to scientific and institutional authority — whether working under it (deferring to consensus framings, or particular organisations such as the IPCC or national bodies), with it (contributing to, extending, or operating within established scientific programmes, institutions, or regimes of measurement), or against it (contesting its adequacy, framing, or completeness). We are interested in how “the science” is invoked as a rhetorical and political resource; how storytelling, narrative, and framing mediate the translation of contested or incomplete evidence into movement positions; and how normative and values-based commitments become entangled with empirical claims during this process. Papers might address climate science and activism, food system transitions, conservation and rewilding conflicts, energy politics, or other sites where environmental knowledge is actively made and remade through social movement practice. The panel aims to build a comparative, cross-movement conversation on authority, evidence, and polarisation in contemporary environmentalism and, in doing so, contribute to wider conversations about crises of truth and legitimacy.

This Panel has 1 pending paper proposal.
Propose paper