to star items.

P080


Listening to Conspiracism: The Conspiracy of Authority and the Authority of Conspiracy 
Convenors:
Loïc Bawidamann (University of Cambridge)
Joseph Webster (University of Cambridge)
Send message to Convenors
Format:
Panel

Short Abstract

‘Conspiracy theorists’ are often dismissed as ‘unhinged’ for rejecting established modes of authority. What can ethnographic accounts of conspiracism reveal about the power of emic epistemic critique (‘the conspiracy of authority’) and counter-critique (‘the authority of conspiracy’)?

Long Abstract

Groups characterised as ‘conspiracy theorists’ are often portrayed as fundamentally problematic and dangerous to secular political orders. Such labels are frequently deployed, from the top-down, by epistemic authorities. Drawing inspiration from James Faubion’s (2001) suggestion that anthropologists and millenarian conspiracists are often strikingly (if disconcertingly) akin, this panel seeks to use ethnography to listen to those labelled ‘conspiracy theorists’ to better understand the power of emic epistemic critique and counter-critique. In doing so, this panel shifts focus onto the epistemic ideas and internal authorities within conspiracist communities themselves: how members understand and challenge external accusations (‘the conspiracy of authority’), and how those accusations shape their own views of authority and society (‘the authority of conspiracy’). What forms of authority do they propose instead? Do they see themselves as opposing epistemic authorities, and how central is this opposition to their lived experience?

By examining different epistemic approaches and conceptions of authority, the panel seeks to understand why particular ideas and communities become contested, and how that contestation shapes the ideas circulating within them.

As authoritarian regimes rise and new authorities redefine reality and truth, the grounds on which people’s knowledge and justifications are built appear to be shifting. Ideas once deemed absurd are now mainstream, while others face renewed epistemic contestation and marginalisation. Learning from communities whose lived experiences have been attacked by epistemic authorities may help us understand not only the sociality of authority and conspiracism, but their emergence within both established and populist political groupings across diverse cultural settings.


Propose paper