Log in to star items.
- Convenors:
-
Miranda Sheild Johansson
(University College London)
Charles Dolph (University College London)
Send message to Convenors
- Discussants:
-
Kelly Fagan Robinson
(University of Cambridge)
Samuel Kirwan (University of Bristol)
Sian Lazar (University of Cambridge)
Kimberly Chong (University College London)
Tone Walford (University College London)
- Format:
- Roundtable
Short Abstract
Modernity imbues numbers with an air of objectivity; yet they are not eternal truths but embedded in cultural systems and practices of counting, measuring, and enumeration. This roundtable explores how numbers acquire an aura of authoritative power and arenas where this is challenged or undermined.
Long Abstract
This roundtable engages questions of ‘authority’ by exploring how numbers are embedded in cultural systems and endowed with authoritative power that is open to challenge. Measurements of value, time and change are often done through numbers, making them key factors of how people conceptualise the world. Modernity tends to imbue numbers with an air of objectivity and unassailability; as such, they can take on authoritative power: you can’t argue with the numbers, the popular saying goes. Yet, anthropological work shows that numbers are not eternal truths but embedded in cultural systems and practices of counting, measuring, and enumeration. Numbers – and their ostensible authority – are therefore contingent constructions which vary across time and space. This roundtable thus proposes a conversation about how numbers acquire an aura of power and objectivity and arenas where their authority is challenged or undermined. Our conversation includes budgets and balance sheets, the disciplinary action of financial statements and debt figures, tax rates and tax gaps, monetary policy, price setting, and inflation, population governance and the measurement of needs, and the numeric imaginaries of gambling. In these arenas numbers are used to evidence past and present and project a future – their authority enables financial and political action. Yet, the epistemic authority of numbers is regularly undermined – through inflation causing havoc with price setting, election fraud and distrust in vote counting, or accusations of fake numbers in scientific measurements of climate change. Claimed and contested, we can count on the enduring salience of numbers.