to star items.

P073


The Misinformed Subject? Ethnographies of Epistemic Authority, Its Global Circulations, Contestations and Accommodations 
Convenors:
Dan Nightingale (UCL)
Amir Massoumian (SOAS University)
Send message to Convenors
Discussant:
Maxime Polleri
Format:
Panel

Short Abstract

Who gets cast as misinformed, and by whom? This panel invites ethnographies of the putative ‘misinformed subject’: how it is produced, lived and contested, and how epistemic authority is claimed, resisted and remade within and beyond the Global North and its naturalised epistemic mainstream.

Long Abstract

Contemporary discourses frame an unfolding epistemic crisis in the Global North through the language of fake news, post-truth along with the terms disinformation and misinformation. Policy responses and expert analyses largely follow an information-centric paradigm (Nightingale 2025). That paradigm includes fact-checking, pre-bunking, content moderation and information literacy, locating the problem in the quality of information and the capacities of those who receive it. Underpinning it is the figure of the “misinformed subject”: credulous, irrational or otherwise deficient, defined against a neutral, rational and informed individual. By casting misinformation as a technical problem of information consumption, this figure depoliticises questions of trust and power. At the same time, it quietly reinscribes who is entitled to know and be believed.

This panel invites ethnographic papers that approach the misinformed subject. We ask how is this figure produced and contested within and beyond the Global North and its institutions. How does the concept of misinformation travel, and what epistemological, political and normative assumptions become visible as it does? How do those labelled misinformed live under, work with, or position themselves against the authorities that name them and what counter-authorities do they recognise? Finally, what ethnographically analogous categories for “not knowing properly” exist outside these explicit discourses? How might they speak to work on agnotology (Proctor and Schiebinger 2008) and apisteology (Eller 2026)?

We invite consideration of topics including but not limited to:

-New religious movements and spirituality

-Conspiracy theories

-Alternative epistemologies

-Scientific and medical controversy

-Radical and fringe politics

-Social media and AI


Propose paper