to star items.

P068


1 paper proposal Propose
Authority of Numbers 
Convenors:
Matti Erasaari (University of Helsinki)
Rodolfo Maggio (University of Helsinki)
Tuomas Tammisto (University of Helsinki)
Hilja Aunela (University of Helsinki)
Send message to Convenors
Format:
Panel

Short Abstract

While anthropology has created a robust critique of the flattening, reductive power of quantification regimes, this panel wants to explore its flip side – the subversive or generative aspect of numbers and the authority bestowed upon them.

Long Abstract

Theodore Porter (1995) once called quantification a technology of distance that allows people to agree on seemingly neutral numbers, particularly where mistrust prevails. More recent scholars of bureaucracy, policy and law (Espeland and Sauder 2016; Merry 2016; Shore and Wright 2024) have emphasized the flattening effects of quantification, all but arguing that quantification systems and standards represent an endpoint or finalisation. This panel takes its inspiration from research on infrastructures and STS (e.g. Bowker and Star 1999; Lampland and Star 2009; Appel, Anand and Gupta 2018) to view the authority of quantification, measures and standards as not just a reductive, but also a generative technology.

We invite authors to discuss how quantification systems are used either to challenge or to support or create new forms of authority and describe their often unexpected effects. We are interested in, for example, ranking systems that generate subversive outcomes; the creative potential of traditional iconometric canons in innovative forms of art; and how numbers are manipulated in divinatory practices all the while bestowing authority. The papers in the panel can be either more conceptual or based on ethnographic cases, or a combination of both.

This Panel has 1 pending paper proposal.
Propose paper