Log in to star items.
- Convenors:
-
Jennifer Clarke
(Gray's School of Art, Robert Gordon University)
Jvan Yazdani (Sapienza University of Rome)
Marc Higgin (CRESSON, Grenoble)
Send message to Convenors
- Format:
- Roundtable
Short Abstract
Power determines what can be done; authority concerns who has the legitimate right to do it. Bringing anthropology and creative research into dialogue, this roundtable asks how practices of knowing, making and inhabiting landscapes establish or contest legitimacy, and who judges their outcomes.
Long Abstract
While power has become a dominant concern in anthropological theory (Ortner 2016), identifying its presence is not enough to explain how authority and legitimacy are established. As Fraser (1981) argues, an encompassing conception of power can obscure distinctions between authority, domination and legitimacy. Working across anthropology and creative practice-based research, this roundtable explores these distinctions through practices of knowing, making and inhabiting landscapes- addressing relations among people, land/space, materials and the more-than human.
We ask, first: on what grounds are particular ways of knowing, organising and intervening authorised, by whom, and to what ends? Second, how do practices of knowing and making establish or transform those grounds? Maps, images, ethnographies, spatial designs and artistic interventions do more than represent existing worlds. Their forms have affordances (Levine 2015), enabling and constraining action, shaping what counts as evidence, and potentially reproducing or challenging the frameworks through which expertise and intervention acquire legitimacy.
Third, how are authority, legitimacy and outcomes related? Methods and interventions help define where processes begin and end, what counts as an outcome, and, crucially, how it is evaluated. Such decisions exercise authority without necessarily justifying it. So how are legitimacy and authority established? Who judges success, and on what grounds? How should intentions, consequences and responsibilities figure in judgements of legitimacy?
Through brief provocations and wider discussion, this roundtable invites diverse perspectives on the politics of authority in the making and inhabiting of landscapes.