to star items.

R008


To Empower or Give Up Power? Lived Experience, Epistemic Authority and the Limits of Representation  
Convenors:
Caroline Ackley (Imperial College London)
Gemma Aellah (BSMS)
Send message to Convenors
Chair:
Jed Stevenson (Durham University)
Discussants:
Fe Stevens (University of Brighton)
Kibur Melese (Addis Ababa University)
Emily Cooper (Patient Experience Research Centre)
Format:
Roundtable

Short Abstract

Who gets to speak, and for whom? Bringing inclusive neglected tropical diseases research, UK patient involvement and anthropological work on climate and health into dialogue, this roundtable explores lived experience, epistemic authority and the limits of representation in knowledge production.

Long Abstract

Who gets to be a researcher, and what happens when the lived experience of a few comes to stand for the lives of millions? Drawing on the provocation To Empower or Give Up Power?, this roundtable brings participatory research with people affected by neglected tropical diseases (NTDs) into conversation with patient and public involvement (PPI) in UK health research, alongside anthropological work on climate, environmental change and health. Both participatory NTD research and PPI seek to open closed spaces of expertise, challenge professional hierarchies and recognise people with lived experience as knowledge producers. These are achievements, but they raise uncomfortable questions about epistemic authority and representation.

More than a billion people are affected by NTDs. What does it mean when 20 or 25 people become researchers? Similar tensions arise in UK PPI, where a handful of contributors may be positioned as representing ‘the patient voice’. Anthropological approaches to climate and health extend these questions by highlighting how experiences of environmental change are unevenly distributed, politically contested and embedded within wider socio-ecological transformations.

Moving beyond celebratory accounts of participation, we ask who selects lived-experience researchers, who controls research questions and resources, and whose knowledge becomes authoritative. Can anyone understand another person’s life, even when they share a condition, experience or environment? And why are lived-experience researchers often expected to be representative when professional researchers are not? Bringing these contexts together, we explore what it means not to include new voices, but to redistribute epistemic authority while acknowledging the limits of representation.

We are particularly looking for proposals to join our roundtable from people with lived experience.


Propose contribution