to star items.

P060


Re/productive health, un/productive values: Considering anthropological theories of values in reproductive healthcare 
Convenors:
Clare Margaret Walker (University of Cambridge)
Sara Jane Renfroe (University of Cambridge)
Send message to Convenors
Discussant:
Janet Perkins (University of Cambridge)
Format:
Panel

Short Abstract

Frames of authority, expertise, and justice are never value-neutral. This panel considers the shape of value within anthropological explorations of reproductive health. We aim to open new dialogues to consider the role of anthropology in reconsidering frameworks and approaches to “good care”.

Long Abstract

This panel platforms the productive and discordant ways how values manifest in encounters between patients and healthcare providers in reproductive health settings. Critical approaches to medical anthropology (Martin 1994; Williamson 2021), taken together with value theory (Graeber 2001; Dilker et al. 2015), set a landscape for understanding how reproductive health knowledge and expertise is, or should be, constructed (Jordan 1997; Ford 2020; Yaetes-Doerr 2023). Following feminist and decolonial approaches to giving and receiving care (Davis 2019; Knight 2020), this panel understands reproductive health as a particularly salient site to explore this negotiation and examine its impact. Our panel is open to:

1) Ethnographic inquiries examining the ways that what we want (or ought to want) emerges and clashes in reproductive healthcare;

2) Explorations of the shape(s) of value in reproductive health, including (but not limited to): obstetric/gynecological clinical care, maternal health, abortion care, and community-based reproductive health initiatives;

3) Methodological and conceptual interventions interrogating the taken-for-granted assumption of medical knowledge as “value-neutral” (Smith-Oka & Spiegel 2023) and its implications for reproductive justice.

We engage with the subtopic “Knowledge, Justification, Critique” as it relates to reproductive health, what makes a care encounter ‘clinical’ (or not), and constitutions of expertise across patients and providers. We aim to examine how best intentions (along with their un/intended consequences) can be disentangled through ethnographic engagement and theoretical inquiry, and we further propose in which directions anthropologists must ‘go’ to interrogate existing frameworks and consider new approaches to reproductive health (and justice) in the care encounter.


Propose paper