Log in to star items.
- Convenors:
-
Jessica Cooper
(University of Edinburgh)
Joel White (The University of Edinburgh)
Send message to Convenors
- Format:
- Panel
Short Abstract
Anthropologists have turned to refusal as a generative formulation of power, especially as against resistance. What are the possibilities, and limits, of ethnographic refusal? How does the ethnographic case contour refusal’s form, and how does refusal become a collective practice?
Long Abstract
Anthropology’s turn towards ethnographic refusal as a methodological and ethical position that challenges an ethnographic ‘will to know’ has posed transformational challenges to the discipline’s central commitments (Simpson, 2007, 2014, 2016; McGranahan, 2014, 2016; Shange 2019). Initially formulated through Indigenous and Black critiques of colonialism, sovereignty and anthropological knowledge production, refusal has since travelled across diverse ethnographic and theoretical terrains, becoming a central analytic for thinking about ethics, political life, archives, care, abolition and method as “a praxis that reorients our attention both to political life and to modes of knowledge” (Thomas, 2024: 101).
While recent work on the topic has continued to explore important grounds in terms of detailing “creative practices of refusal” (Campt, 2017: 32) and questioning the possibilities of refusal within systems of anti-Blackness (André-Johnson, 2026), less attention has been paid to the concept’s relational and durational forms: how refusals endure, accumulate, bind and separate people. Here, particularly in contexts marked by forced movement, precarity and waiting (Khosravi, 2024; Giordano, 2020) – including borders, carceral sites, medical institutions and the broader “edge spaces” of capitalism (Bhattacharyya, 2019:9) – the stakes and relational affordances of refusal take on particular forms.
This panel creates space to share ethnographic work that consider refusal within such contexts, and to unpack the notion of ethnographic refusal more broadly. In that sense, we further read the anthropological turn to the concept refusal in part symptomatically: what does the enthusiasm about this turn illuminate about methodology, consent, ethics and contemporary anthropological knowledge-making?