to star items.

P057


On whose authority do we speak of values? The omnivore’s dilemma 
Convenors:
Morgan Jenatton (University of Manchester)
Julia Perczel (University of Manchester)
Send message to Convenors
Format:
Panel

Short Abstract

Anthropologies of value stake claims around different reference points, pushing us to pick an orthodoxy. Yet interlocutors rarely live by one logic of values, and a world in flux calls for theoretical pluralism. We invite ethnographies that make the case for an omnivorous anthropology of values.

Long Abstract

Thinking through values is thorny terrain. It can at times seem to mean choosing one’s tribe. Labour, the gift, exchange, relationality, the good life, market devices, creative action: each has its school, dividing the field and us with it (Otto and Willerslev 2013). Lean towards relationality and our Marxian friends frown at our soft liberalism; dwell on our interlocutors’ pursuit of profit and we are told market logics have clouded our gaze.

Yet, we argue, people ‘out in the world’ rarely adhere to a single logic of values. One person may use market devices to raise profits while honouring ritual reciprocity elsewhere. Another may pursue the good life by exploiting the underpaid labour of kin. We observe that growing financialisation, ever wider global circulation, mass movement of people, and environmental degradation are throwing systems of values into flux. As ethnographers, we must be able to trace these various modalities of values that inform how people make life work, yet anthropological conventions sometimes force us to choose between orthodoxies.

We contend that this shifting landscape calls for another take on value transformations. How do we trace the ways our interlocutors stitch together seemingly incompatible registers of value, and how do we reconcile divergent theories of values? We invite ethnographically-grounded papers in which two or more theories of values seem to be in play: cases that call for bringing together schools not normally placed in the same frame. That is, contexts that feed the omnivorous need to draw on multiple anthropological authorities.


Propose paper