to star items.

P049


Machinic Authority: Delegation, Interpretation, and Refusal  
Convenors:
Hannah Knox (University of Manchester)
Jennifer Cearns (University of Manchester)
Send message to Convenors
Format:
Panel

Short Abstract

This panel asks how machines become authoritative, and what their acceptance or refusal reveals about the power relations through which they become consequential agents of social change.

Long Abstract

From AI companions to smart devices and distributed infrastructures, technical systems are entering intimate spaces of social life, where they may be welcomed, accommodated or violently rejected. This panel asks how machines become authoritative, and what their acceptance or refusal reveals about the power relations through which they become consequential agents of social change.

We distinguish authority from trust and habituation. Following Asad (1993), we treat authority as produced through authorising processes, discipline and institutional arrangements. Building on Latour’s (2005) distributed agency and Gell’s (1998) anthropology of art and agency, we ask how technical systems come to count as more than mute objects: entities whose outputs or presence warrant attention and response. Work on mediation (Engelke 2007; Meyer 2011), AI’s religious imaginary (Singler 2020), and technical systems as forms of divination used to navigate uncertainty (Cearns & Knox 2024; Cearns 2025), opens a further question: how do practices of consultation and interpretation make a system’s outputs authoritative, even when uncertain or contested?

Three concepts organise the panel. Delegation: whose authority does a system carry, and how visible is this to those living with it? Interpretation: who is authorised to read a system’s outputs, and what makes those readings credible? Refusal: what happens when delegation or interpretation fails, and what does that reveal about the conditions on which authority depends?

We invite ethnographies of diverse technologies that explore how machinic authority is made, whose interests it serves, and how its limits become apparent.


Propose paper