Log in to star items.
- Convenors:
-
Maxim Bolt
(University of Oxford)
Myfanwy James (LSE)
Send message to Convenors
- Format:
- Panel
Short Abstract
How do governing institutions constitute authority amid moral dissensus and mutual suspicion? This panel examines attempts to achieve authority where people disagree on what such institutions should stand for, and where disagreement and mistrust call motives, commitments and loyalties into question.
Long Abstract
How are forms of institutional authority constituted and undermined in contexts of moral dissensus and widespread mutual suspicion? This panel examines attempts by state and other governing institutions to establish authority, in settings where people fundamentally disagree on what such institutions are meant to stand for, and where deep disagreement and mistrust call motives, commitments and loyalties into question. The panel builds on anthropological scholarship about how states and state-like institutions are constituted as authoritative. Seminal ethnographic work illuminates authority from the institutional margins, and amid resistance, evasion and subversion; its dependence on official and unofficial institutional work; its equal reliance on fantasies of power and possibility; and its routinely violent effects. We aim to go beyond these concerns. We explore settings where institutions strive for but are unable effectively to ground governing in shared values, and where constituting authority may also immediately undermine it. Governing institutions are woven into people’s priorities, projects and relationships by mediating between competing moral claims, bridging plural normative orders, and recruiting intermediaries to do so. As they adjudicate intractable disputes, authority is not only negotiated and provisional, but often contradictory and self-undermining. Institutions’ efforts to assert legitimacy, by putting themselves on the line, can also erode it. As people manage uncertainty, mistrust reconfigures institutional arrangements. We welcome papers that consider how institutions position themselves within such social worlds, how their own mediating practices unsettle their claims, and which ethnographic and theoretical approaches best capture authority that is simultaneously made and unmade in the process.