to star items.

P040


Co-Authoring the State: Complicity, Fabrication, and the Hermeneutics of Bureaucratic Authority  
Convenors:
Puja-Arti Patel (University of Warwick)
Alejandro Porcel Arraut (University of Cambridge)
Daniel Woodward (University of Warwick)
Send message to Convenors
Format:
Panel

Short Abstract

This panel asks how front-line bureaucrats, brokers, and citizens co-author the state’s "truths" through lies, forged signatures, and bent rules, and whether authority built on such complicity works differently under authoritarian and liberal-democratic regimes.

Long Abstract

Following calls to approach the state from below, this panel asks how “truths” for the state are co-authored at its frontlines, and whether this differs between authoritarian regimes and liberal democracies. If authority rests on acknowledgment rather than obedience (Gadamer 2004 [1960]), and is neither coercion nor persuasion (Arendt 1961), what sustains it when no one believes the official version, as when a bureaucrat helps an applicant lie, or when citizens act “as if” they believe a regime’s claims (Wedeen 2015 [1999])? Does the conviviality between rulers and ruled (Mbembe 1992) bind both to shared fictions? How different are these from the coached testimonies that asylum systems demand (Cabot 2014)? Such co-authorship may reveal where liberal-democratic and authoritarian forms of state authority overlap and where they diverge, opening entry points into lived experiences of the state across time and political contexts.

We invite papers on each of the state’s co-authors. When do bureaucrats’ and citizens’ dealings with the state blur into “corruption” (Gupta 1995), and can a fake be “clean” (Reeves 2013)? Must officials disavow the fixers they depend on (Degani 2024)? Are bureaucrats who bend rules tempered radicals (Meyerson and Scully 1995), or does their discretion sustain the state (Lipsky 1980)? What becomes of these fictions when decisions pass to automated systems that cannot be persuaded or made complicit (Eubanks 2018)? We welcome papers engaging with testimony (Shuman and Bohmer 2004), everyday practice (Fuller and Harriss 2001), or stamps, seals, and paper (Hull 2012; Navaro-Yashin 2007).


Propose paper