Log in to star items.
- Convenors:
-
Adam Reed
(St. Andrews University)
Soumhya Venkatesan (University of Manchester)
Send message to Convenors
- Format:
- Panel
Short Abstract
This panel will explore the diverse ways in which knowledge claims are linked to the authority of the book, and to ways in which the reported absence of that authority itself becomes an authoritative claim (whether in legal, religious or academic traditions).
Long Abstract
In this panel, we are interested in exploring the diverse ways in which knowledge claims are linked to the authority of the book, and to ways in which the reported absence of that authority itself becomes an authoritative claim. Moving between diverse fields (for example, legal traditions that privilege canonical law, religious traditions that privilege sacred text, or academic traditions that privilege great works), the panel asks how the authority of the book connects not just to the authority to know but also to the authority to speak and the authority to conclude or draw judgement. How is the authority of the book precisely claimed, through what manoeuvres and techniques (i.e. citation, precedent, discernment, quotation)? Likewise, how is that authority resisted, both within and outside those traditions? For instance, by associating that authority with a concept like dogma or convention or orthodoxy, or with a relational form like hierarchy; or staying within a particular tradition, by making an internal distinction between forms of authority (such as the modern legal theory that presumes ‘law in the books’ can be held apart from ‘law in action’). And what precisely is at stake in claiming to exist within a given tradition that explicitly rejects the authority of the book? For instance, by invoking a relational form like equality or inclusivity, or a counter concept like common sense or intuition or freedom, or just by invoking a horizon that is imagined to be a democratic opening of our entitlement to speak or know.