Log in to star items.
- Convenors:
-
Susan Hyatt
(Indiana University Indianapolis)
Sasha Maher (Copenhagen Business School)
Send message to Convenors
- Discussant:
-
Cris Shore
(Goldsmiths University of London)
- Format:
- Panel
Short Abstract
Drawing on a range of contexts, papers in this panel ask, how can anthropology contribute to debates about the proliferation of post-evidentiary policies shaped solely by political ideologies without even any pretense of scientific evidence? How do such policies gain and sustain their legitimacy?
Long Abstract
Politicians and governments typically argue that their public policies are based on sound and reasoned judgement, robust evidence, and rational expertise – key principles upon which policies historically have established their legitimacy and authority. By contrast, anthropologists have shown how policies, particularly those promoting neoliberal economic agendas, are also driven by ideological and political interests, even if these are disguised or deliberately understated. Today it seems that many politicians no longer even pretend that their policies transcend political self-interest. The present moment is giving way to the production of policy initiatives that now eschew completely any claim to being based in science or evidence. The neoliberal era has also enabled – and, indeed, established the basis for – the emergence of a much darker vision of society that in many liberal democratic nation-states is shading toward authoritarianism. In autocratic non-Western states that never experienced neoliberalism, the role played by policy has perhaps not been as thoroughly interrogated as it has been in other contexts. Drawing on a range of settings, the papers in this panel ask, how can anthropology contribute to debates about the proliferation of post-evidentiary policies, shaped solely by political and ideological considerations without any appeals to scientific evidence? How do such policies gain legitimacy? What role can anthropology play in illuminating the shifting role of policy in an increasingly undemocratic world?