to star items.

P016


Epistemic Registers of Authority in Medicine & Anthropology 
Convenors:
Shagufta Bhangu (King's College London)
Mauricio Najarro (King's College London)
Send message to Convenors
Format:
Panel

Short Abstract

How are anthropological and medical knowledges crafted and contested through bodily practices, gestures, stories, images, documents and silences? This panel explores how forms of expression and mediation shape clinical knowledge, relations of care, and anthropologists's own claims to authority.

Long Abstract

Both anthropological and medical authority take shape through bodily practices, gestures, stories, images, documents and silences whose meaning and evidentiary force remains open to contestation. This panel examines how different forms of telling, depiction and mediation establish, sustain or unsettle authority in medicine—and in anthropological accounts of it.

Our panel will bring together discussions on the relational networks constituted through gestures in a pain clinic, confessional storytelling among people who use drugs, the interplay of disclosure, silences, and withholding, and the authority of bodies rendered on paper. What makes a gesture persuasive, a silence telling, an image real, a confession credible or a document authoritative? How do silence and the unsaid shape what can be known, by whom and with what consequences? These questions draw attention to the disparate registers at work in knowing in medicine.

The panel also turns these questions towards ethnographic practice. Anthropologists work across registers of evidence: spoken accounts, embodied encounters, visual materials, documentary traces, and absent presences. How does movement between these registers authorise particular interpretations while foreclosing others? What responsibilities arise when an ethnographer turns a gesture into a description, a silence into an argument or another person’s story into a published text? Bringing medical and anthropological authority into the same frame, we ask how practices of representation distribute credibility, sustain relations of care and establish—or contest—the right to speak for others.

We welcome papers which sit with these tensions and consider these registers which underpin medical and anthropological epistemic authority.


Propose paper