to star items.

P013


Whodunnit? Attribution as Social Technique  
Convenors:
Ana Chiritoiu (Uppsala University)
Rik Adriaans (University College London)
Send message to Convenors
Format:
Panel

Short Abstract

Societies attach effects to sources: misfortune to a witch, an accident to a chain where nobody is liable. Attribution settles authorship, credit and blame. We invite ethnographic papers on how attribution is made, owned, laundered, declined, or undone.

Long Abstract

Societies run on attaching effects to sources: misfortune to a witch, a sound to a performer, an accident to a chain where nobody is liable. Anthropology has studied such attributions since Evans-Pritchard, but under separate headings. From Gluckman’s The Allocation of Responsibility (1972) to Gell’s Art and Agency (1998), attribution has moved from the moral to the aesthetic, from persons to objects. We resume this lineage under new conditions: liability crossing borders, atmospheres altered by everyone and no one, machines that write without being authors.

To name a source is to settle authorship, credit, and blame: who gains and who must answer. A relation rather than a fact, attribution can be claimed, delegated, laundered, diffused, declined. And yet, not everyone can make an attribution stick, or refuse one. In conspiracy it runs to excess, furnishing authors for effects that seem to have none; in sorcery and other arts of imperceptibility, to deficit, leaving effects without authors; in the public secret it is suspended, known to all, named by none; in generative art it is cut, in operations that separate artist from algorithm.

Attribution is also about explanation. Our interlocutors often explain less through causal mechanics than through moral responsibility, tying an outcome to something, or someone, that can be held to account. Ethnographic writing similarly reads agency into fragments.

We welcome ethnographic papers on blame (witchcraft, conspiracy, audit, loopholes); credit and creation (cultural property, machine-made work, authorship, sampling); evidence and exposure (testimony, whistleblowing, climate attribution); and imperceptibility (masking, inspiration, erasure).


Propose paper