to star items.

P001


War and Error: Promise, Limit, and Refusal of Military Authority in the Age of Precision Warfare 
Convenors:
Nomi Stone (University of Texas, Dallas)
Ahmad Moradi (Leibniz-Zentrum Moderner Orient (ZMO))
Marieke Brandt (Austrian Academy of Sciences)
Send message to Convenors
Format:
Panel

Short Abstract

In mock villages, military databases and scenarios, wars are composed in advance, imagined and presented as error-free. We ask how people live under, work with and act against military authority built on precision, how its errors are framed and contested, and how anthropology can challenge it.

Long Abstract

Much of modern military authority draws on the pretension to master war before it is fought. In mock Iraqi villages where role-players act out war for US soldiers in training, as in military databases that create ‘perfect target packages’ ahead of AI-assisted targeting, war is composed in advance, i.e. imagined and presented as error-free. Carl von Clausewitz, the nineteenth-century Prussian general whose writings remain the foundation of Western military thought, treated error as ‘friction’ and as an ordinary medium of war. Regimes of precision warfare, however, stake their legitimacy on eliminating error. Each ‘tragic mistake’ is therefore framed as an aberration and tied to promises of procedural reform and greater precision. Following Hannah Arendt, we read the promise of precision as self-defeating, since no apparatus can secure the whole ground of the future.

The panel asks how people live under, work with and act against military authority built on precision, in war and in militarised environments. For those who live under it, calculative logic sorts them into targets and acceptable losses. Others work with it, from role-players and interpreters to migrant fighters, contractors and engineers. Families of the dead, investigators and militant resisters contest the classifications and the very machinery that authorise killing and fight back the official accounts that try to explain error away. We welcome ethnographic contributions and ask how anthropological knowledge can elucidate or challenge the epistemic authority claimed by modern and AI-assisted warfare, and what place ethnographic refusal has in that work.


Propose paper