to star items.

P010


Who Gets to Judge? Critique, Standing, and Contested Authority 
Convenors:
Nicholas Lackenby (University College London)
Ori Mautner (University of Cambridge)
Send message to Convenors
Format:
Panel

Short Abstract

Critique rests on relations of authority: who possesses the knowledge, experience, or moral standing to judge others? We invite papers examining how the standing to criticise is made, recognised, and refused, and how it shapes the effects of critique.

Long Abstract

Critique is commonly imagined as directed against authority. Yet criticism itself rests on relations of authority: claims about who possesses the knowledge, experience, or moral standing from which others may legitimately be judged. Foucault’s account of power as the “conduct of conduct” draws attention to power exercised upon subjects who remain capable of reflection and refusal (Laidlaw 2014). Pragmatic sociology foregrounds actors’ capacities for criticism and justification (Boltanski & Thévenot 2006; Boltanski 2011). Recent ethnographies show how political and historical judgement becomes entangled with struggles over recognition and moral positioning (Lackenby 2025; Mautner 2026). Less examined is how the standing to criticise is produced and contested.

Scheler’s account of ressentiment illuminates that when perceived injury cannot be acted upon or resolved, hostile feeling may be repeatedly relived. This dynamic can become entangled with contested histories and frustrated recognition claims (Lackenby forthcoming). Across social worlds, people distinguish between criticism they recognise as legitimate and judgements whose authors lack the standing to make them. Crucially, contesting a critic’s standing does not necessarily entail rejecting a critique’s content: people may make similar judgements in other circumstances while denying certain actors the authority to make them. What happens when people agree with a critique but reject the critic’s authority? How does a critic’s standing shape whether critique persuades, generates counter-critique, fuels ressentiment, or intensifies attachments the critic seek to loosen? We invite papers examining how the standing to criticise is made, recognised, and refused across diverse social worlds—including critiques with which anthropologists often agree.


Propose paper