to star items.

R016


Anthropologists and Our Expert Others: how can we work with, against, and alongside other professionalised ways of knowing? 
Convenors:
Alanna Cant (University of Reading)
Caroline Bennett (University of Sussex, School of Global Studies)
Send message to Convenors
Format:
Roundtable

Short Abstract

In this roundtable, we will explore the epistemic and ethical issues that arise when anthropologists engage with other forms of professional expertise. The discussion will ask how we can navigate these interactions while championing anthropological perspectives.

Long Abstract

In this roundtable, we will explore what happens when anthropologists work on topics or areas in which other experts (those in other discplines, professionals, or even 'professional amateurs') already have established ways of knowing, working, and/or addressing ethical issues. Building on Harvey and Knox's notion of ‘impossibility’ (2015), the condition that arises when expertise and practice fail to translate cleanly across domains, we want to explore the disconnections that can arise in such work, in order to consider how anthropologists might productively navigate challenges and champion anthropological perspectives beyond our immediate audiences.

We welcome all participants who want to examine anthropology's relationship to experts, including other anthropologists themselves. We may discuss:

• Experiences working with scientific, medical, legal, forensic, archaeological, bureaucratic, research support or other technical experts;

• Competing claims to authority over people, bodies, objects, places, histories or forms of evidence;

• The commitments and challenges anthropology brings to these encounters, and how these shift across different subfields. What happens when our own subfields disagree?

• What do such encounters mean for anthropology's claim to a distinctive way of knowing?

• The limits, possibilities and responsibilities of anthropological critique when other experts' perspectives may carry greater institutional or public weight;

• The impact of disagreements or disconnections between different kinds of experts on audiences beyond the academy, including practitioners, policy-makers, and the public.


Propose contribution