to star items.

P003


Anthropologists and Scriptural Authority: Reading the Repugnant Other  
Convenors:
Tarina Franklin (University of Cambridge)
Annastiina Kallius (Helsinki Collegium for Advanced Studies)
Send message to Convenors
Discussant:
Liana Chua (University of Cambridge)
Format:
Panel

Short Abstract

Intellectual canons other than our own can be repugnant yet shape the contexts of what we work with. Exploring how anthropologists engage with them reveals the boundaries of our disciplinary knowledge. How do anthropologists relate to scriptural authority they dislike?

Long Abstract

The worlds anthropologists encounter during their research do not come as a tabula rasa but include their own intellectual canons and textual sources of authority, whose presence echoes through ethnographic fieldwork in different ways. Our interlocutors can challenge or draw inspiration from sources of written authority such as court rulings, fascist novels, multimedia content, biologically determinist statements, reports of violence and genocide, fiscal strategy documents that justify austerity, or entire scholarly canons such as classical economics. This panel explores how anthropologists engage with the ‘repugnant’ scriptural authority that informs ethnographic contexts. Where do we stop reading, and why? What makes a different intellectual canon difficult to read? Or, do we on occasions resort to reading uncomfortable materials in cases where in-person ethnographic work is even more repulsive? We invite papers that discuss how anthropologists have engaged with the textual epistemic authorities of their research worlds, such as colonial administrative documents, bioessentialist historical or natural scientific literature, or social media posts inciting racial or religious hatred. In examining how anthropologists relate to scriptural authority – when they flinch and when they engage, and how such texts find their way into our theorisation – we explore the limits of anthropological knowledge.


Propose paper