Paper short abstract:

This qualitative study analyzes the impact that “structural competency,” an emerging framework for helping clinicians navigate social processes within the health system, had on medical students’ and physicians’ understanding of societal problems affecting patient health and health system practices.

Paper long abstract:

In this study, we analyze the impact that “structural competency,” an emerging framework for helping clinicians navigate social processes within the health system, had on medical students’ and physicians’ understanding of societal problems affecting patient health. In this qualitative study conducted between August and December 2020, we analyzed 19 semi-structured interviews with 7 first-year medical students, 7 upper-level medical students, and 5 physician course facilitators who participated in a course called Introduction to Medicine and Society at an medical school in the United States affiliated with a large urban academic medical center. This paper focuses on three main findings: how medical students and faculty describe “structures” and their effects on patients and patient care; how they use or imagine using structural competency to improve patient-physician communication and work inter-professionally to address social needs; and the emotional and personal reactions that confronting societal challenges provokes. We conclude that structural competency enhances existing efforts to improve patient-physician communication and to address patients’ social needs. However, we highlight how structural competency efforts might fall short of their goal to shift physicians’ perspectives “upstream” to the determinants of health due to both critical ambiguities in the concept and inattention to the emotional and personal impacts of addressing societal problems in the clinic. These findings have practical implications for how clinicians are trained to act on societal issues from within the health system and conceptual implications for refining how existing frameworks and curricula conceive of the intersection between healthcare and broader processes.